I think that I have come to definitive conclusion about whether or not I liked my book: not really. First off, the end was slightly sad, and slightly pleasurable depending on how you look at it. The book ends by Amory crying that he knows himself, "but that is all". For one thing, my prediction came true. The book ended with Amory being alone and depressed because he pushed everyone away from him. This was no surprise at all, and was a little satisfying because after many of the things that happen in the book, I simply just do not like Amory as a person, and i feel that after his entire life, he made no adjustments to be a good person or anything. In my opinion, the book ended the way that it should have because he didn't develop at all.
And that was one of the reasons why i didn't like the book. One of the main things i said that i was excited to read about in the first blog post was the development that Amory made throughout his life. After reading the back i figured that some sort of character development was inevitable, not only because it is apparent in nearly every story i have ever read, but because he is a person who gets no results out of his actions. That is a person who you would expect to develop and change, right? Wrong. I am not exactly sure what Mr. Fitzgerald was thinking when he wrote this, because it simply made Amory more and more annoying as the book went on. In the last section, he mentions his mother's death in a letter to his great friend Darcy. He speaks about it in an emotionless manner, and even seems annoyed a bit when mentioning the fact that she left most of her wealth to the church. This was the point of no return for me as a reader, because as soon as he disgraced his mother simply because she didn't leave him enough money, i decided that he didn't deserve the happiness that i once hoped he would achieve. in that sense, the book was a success, but if you look at if from Amory's point of view, it really is a sad sad story. The boy was born to an extravagant mother who brought him up to be the way he is, and as a result of the war, he ends up emotionless. However it is not his background that makes me hate him, that can be excused. It was his inability to change that annoyed me, he seemed to get worse with this egotism, arrogance, and pomposity throughout the novel.
In addition to just the actual story, i thought it was lacking in general. For example, the entire book followed only one person in detail. This might have been okay if that one character was extremely interesting, like-able, or changed a lot throughout the book, but Amory was none of those things. I think the addition of more characters would have made the book less boring and a lot more exciting. Another thing was the dead spots. They made the book very hard to read because they would discourage me from wanting to turn the page. However, regardless of all of this, I think that if i did learn something from this book, it is who i should never be. I see the things that Amory did, and the way it affected him, and it brought him nowhere but to loneliness. Not only that specifically, but i also learned just the general importance of being able to change. I see now that it can be crippling if one is not able to adapt or change when their situation or strategy is not working. For this, i guess i am thankful, but in all honesty, i would have liked to be taught these lessons in a different way with a more interesting book.
Hey Josh, I'm sorry the book didn't turn out so great. Sometimes, we just have to grit our teeth and read through, in the best interests of our grade! But you got through it, and now you're done with it! From what you've said, I probably wouldn't like to read this book. Nice job on this whole blog project man. Peace out.
ReplyDeleteHey Josh, sounds like your book wasn't so interesting after all. Pretty cool that your prediction came true though. I also wonder what the author was thinking with Amory's character. It seems so odd that he would write the whole story based around him, yet not show a lot of development. I would have also been frustrated by this. But, like Allen said, at least your done with it now. Good job on the post.
ReplyDeleteJosh -
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry your book wasn't too good. It seems like it was really predictable, considering you knew the end from when you first started reading, which is unfortunate. You also said you didn't think the character developed too much, but didn't he realize in the end that love was important after all? He may not have acted on his development, but it seems like his views did change in the end. After your review I probably wouldn't pick this book up, so thanks for the warning!
Josh,
ReplyDeleteIt's a bummer that your book did not turn out being that good after all. It's pretty disappointing when you devote all of that time to a book just to not like it in the end. I found what you said at the end to be very interesting. When you said the book taught you what not to be, it made me think a little bit. Do you think it was possible that the author intended for this to happen? Maybe this book was more about sending a message than telling a story? If that was the case the author looks like he wrote a pretty good book! Either way, after hearing the way you described the book in your last post, I don't think I would chose to read it now. Good Post Giacalone
hey josh, your book seemed ineresting at first and i was excited to read what crazy event happened next! But unfortunately, it was a let down, and judging from how disappointed I was, I can only imagine how bored you were with the result and your book. Although it is quite anti climatic that the book seems to have no character development for Amory at all, I do believe the author could have done this for a fairly good reason. Why are authors publishing works if they don't really know how to write? I'd say that the author is trying to teach us that sometimes, there isn't anything you can do to change anything. With the constant hope of Amory to become a better person, and constant disappointment, I feel the author was showing that life isn't a fairy tale there aren't always going to be great endings. That's what life is, sometimes it will screw you over and you got to deal with that. The lack of change can also show that a person is who the person is, seldom/difficult for something to change someone. On a side note, I do agree that his irritation towards his mother ticked me off as well! Your suggestions for a better book overall is good, maybe talk to the author and shoot him an email haha. Aright wellg good readings josh, toodles
ReplyDelete